Okay, I'm not naming names here. if you know who I am talking about, you know. but you don't need to know the specifics of which fan wank this is now. The specifics are not the point.
What has currently set my hair on fire actually applies to more than just fanfic, I realized, but to art as well, particularly from my perspective as a not-creator - as a reader, or a viewer, or a listener, or a sniffer.
well the topic came up becuase somebody posted that she wished that someone *hadn't* posted warnings on a work of original fiction, because it ended up acting as a kind of spoiler, and then went on to muse about the function of warnings in FanFic.
Well, okay. when I post fanfic, I do fill in the standard form thingies, but you can kind of tell by the way i fill them out that I think they are kind of dumb. it's one of those cultural things. and they serve as tags to let you know if you want to read the story - if you're only about a certain pairing, you can tell at a glance if it's for you, etc. so no serious objections, except thinking grumbly thoughts at Tipper Gore*.
but in the comments, somebody piped up to disagree with the original poster who questioned the function of warning headers to say that s/he was "appalled" that the op would dare to suggest that warnings in fanfic headers be done away with, and that it has been done this way from lo these many years ago when fanfic was golden and you whippersnappers were just a gleam in harry potter's eye. (God, I have had my *fill* of old-timers these days. srsly.)
It was quickly (repeated) that original and professionally published fiction does not carry any such warnings, and if a writer doesn't have to warn on pro fic, then why should s/he have to for fanfic?
and the person who disagreed said that the reason was (the author's sense of) personal responsibility.
(hair lights on fire right about here)
Um. excuse me? are you somehow incapable of exercising personal responsibility, and so you figure it's your Eris-given right to demand that everyone take care of you?
No, sorry. If you're old enough to gas on about the good old days, then you had better be an adult, and part of being an adult is being responsible for yourself. I'm not going to infantilize you even if you demand it.
And then this person went on to explain that THE AUTHOUR'S sense of personal responsibility was rooted in empathizing with a potion of potential readers who *might possibly* have a problem with a particular theme. zomg...
Bitch, PLEASE. If *YOU* have something that makes you react this incredibly strongly, that is *YOUR* problem. I have problems of my own. I do not need yours; nor am I interested in them.
I am a fan of Harry Potter. I don't have an OTP (though I do prefer slash) and there is very little in the body of fanfic that I will refuse to read, once you eliminate bad writing from the list. I have read things that disturbed my hair straight. in fact, my favorite hands down HP fanfic writer has made me go "eeeeuygh!" and step away from the story so I can take the time to decide if I want to go on, or not. (I haven't ever turned away yet, but I do take the time to decide. but that thing with the beetles - eeeee) It's all fine, whatever.
but I am also a fan of a TV show, Criminal Minds. and I read fanfic set for that, except I utterly refuse to read any story that revolves around any of the characters in a romantic or sexual relationship, because it really hits my unacceptable buttons with this show. it's just... no. please. you can't convince me that there's even the needed room for speculation there between the characters.
so do I run around telling people that they have to pander to my desires because they should feel a sense of personal responsibility rooted in empathy for my possible, potential problems? no, because that's so irrationally self-centered I'd have to have an Axis II personality disorder to make it seem like an okay thing to do.
I have the right to stumble across material that frightens, disturbs, sickens, or enrages me, and I have the perfect right to do that by accident. if an author wishes to warn me about content, well, I think that's pretty tragic, and I remember tipper gore with contempt*, but it's up to them to do so. I don't need them to do it. I do not need to be protected.
So why do people think they can get away with demanding crap like that from fanfic writers? or are these the same idjits who ban books, burn books, suppress books, protest statues of the nummy chocolate jesus? (dis my body! you eats it nau.) or the meat dress? (Dis my fashion statement! better not eats it, tho)
Or are these people hypocrites? do these people scorn those people who think that Harry Potter promotes satanism, and go rah rah on freedom to read week and trot out lists of the forbidden books they've read, but feel that they can suppress fanfic because it's not real art?
I'm not sure which one would piss me off more, frankly.
*
though the song that started it all was pretty damn dirty, yo